Table of Contents
- Introduction: The Evolution of Women’s Football
- Defining Greatness in Women’s Football
- The Historical Giants: Pioneers Who Shaped the Game
- Modern Era Contenders for Best Women’s Footballer
- Aitana Bonmatí: The Current Queen of Football
- Statistical Analysis: Comparing the Greatest
- Impact Beyond the Pitch
- The Next Generation: Rising Stars
- Expert Opinions and Analysis
- Measuring Success: Trophies and Individual Awards
- Cultural Impact and Legacy
- Comparative Analysis: Different Eras
- Frequently Asked Questions
- Conclusion: Defining the Best Women’s Footballer
Introduction: The Evolution of Women’s Football
The quest to determine who is the best women’s footballer has evolved significantly alongside the sport itself. From the early days of pioneers like Lily Parr to the modern excellence of players like Aitana Bonmatí, women’s football has undergone a remarkable transformation. This comprehensive analysis delves deep into the factors that define greatness in women’s football and examines the players who have laid legitimate claim to being the best.
The journey of women’s football represents one of sport’s most compelling narratives. Despite facing numerous obstacles, including outright bans in countries like England (1921-1971), the women’s game has flourished to become one of the fastest-growing sports globally. This growth has produced exceptional talents whose skills and achievements have redefined what’s possible in football.

Defining Greatness in Women’s Football
To identify who is the best women’s footballer, we must first establish the criteria for greatness. Unlike men’s football, which has enjoyed consistent professional structures for over a century, women’s football has developed under unique circumstances that demand specific consideration.
Key Criteria for Evaluation:
- Technical Excellence: Ball control, passing accuracy, shooting precision
- Tactical Intelligence: Game reading ability, positional awareness, decision-making
- Physical Attributes: Speed, strength, endurance, and adaptation to modern demands
- Leadership and Impact: Influence on teammates and ability to change games
- Legacy: Contribution to the development of women’s football
- Achievement: Individual awards, team trophies, and records
Criteria | Importance | Measurable Metrics |
---|---|---|
Technical Skills | Critical | Pass completion %, shot accuracy, successful dribbles |
Tactical Acumen | High | Assists, key passes, interceptions |
Physical Performance | Important | Distance covered, sprint speed, stamina indicators |
Leadership | Significant | Captaincy roles, teammate testimonials |
Legacy | Notable | Impact on game development, inspiring next generation |
The Historical Giants: Pioneers Who Shaped the Game
The discussion of who is the best women’s footballer must acknowledge the tremendous impact of historical figures who laid the foundation for today’s stars. These pioneers achieved excellence despite limited resources and recognition.
Lily Parr (1905-1978)
The first woman inducted into the English Football Hall of Fame, Parr scored over 900 goals in her career, demonstrating remarkable skill when women’s football was in its infancy. Her powerful shot was legendary, reportedly breaking a male goalkeeper’s arm during a training session.
Michelle Akers (1966-present)
A true pioneer of modern women’s football, Akers dominated the inaugural 1991 Women’s World Cup, showcasing unprecedented athletic ability and scoring prowess. Her versatility in playing both as a striker and midfielder set new standards for complete footballers.
“Michelle Akers was the best women’s footballer I have ever seen. Her combination of physical presence, technical skill, and tactical understanding was years ahead of her time.” – April Heinrichs, former USWNT Head Coach
Modern Era Contenders for Best Women’s Footballer
The modern era has produced several exceptional players who have legitimate claims to being the best women’s footballer. Their achievements have been documented and celebrated on a global stage, allowing for more detailed analysis of their contributions.
Marta Vieira da Silva
Often referred to as “Pelé in skirts” (a nickname she dislikes but which speaks to her impact), Marta has:
- Six FIFA World Player of the Year awards
- Record goalscorer in World Cup history (men’s and women’s)
- Transformed the technical aspects of women’s football
Megan Rapinoe
A complete footballer whose influence extends beyond the pitch:
- Two World Cup victories
- Ballon d’Or Féminin winner
- Olympic gold medallist
- Crucial role in advancing equality in football
Sam Kerr
The Australian striker has revolutionized the role of forward in women’s football:
- All-time leading scorer in NWSL and Australian W-League
- First female footballer to lead scoring charts in three different leagues
- Famous for her consistent goal-scoring ability and spectacular finishes
Aitana Bonmatí: The Current Queen of Football
As of 2023-2024, Aitana Bonmatí has emerged as the leading candidate for best women’s footballer. Her achievements include:
Recent Accolades:
- 2023 Ballon d’Or Féminin winner
- 2023 World Cup winner and tournament’s best player
- UEFA Women’s Champions League victory with Barcelona
- Spanish Liga F championship
Playing Style Analysis:
Bonmatí’s excellence lies in her complete mastery of midfield play:
Aspect | Description | Impact |
---|---|---|
Technical Control | Exceptional first touch and close control | Maintains possession under pressure |
Vision | Elite passing range and decision-making | Creates opportunities for teammates |
Positioning | Intelligent movement between lines | Controls game tempo and space |
Physical | Outstanding balance and acceleration | Escapes pressure effectively |
Statistical Analysis: Comparing the Greatest
To determine who is the best women’s footballer, we must examine statistical evidence across different eras and competitions. Here’s a comprehensive comparison of key metrics:
Career Statistics of Elite Players
Player | Goals | Assists | Trophies | Individual Awards |
---|---|---|---|---|
Marta | 171 | 163 | 12 | 6 FIFA POTY |
Aitana Bonmatí | 42 | 35 | 15 | 1 Ballon d’Or |
Sam Kerr | 238 | 114 | 8 | 2 EAFC POTY |
Ada Hegerberg | 185 | 76 | 14 | 1 Ballon d’Or |
These statistics tell only part of the story. When analyzing who is the best women’s footballer, we must consider the context of each player’s achievements. For instance, Marta’s goal-scoring record is particularly impressive given that she played in an era with less developed professional structures. Meanwhile, Bonmatí’s influence on games extends beyond pure statistics, with her ability to control matches and create opportunities for teammates being paramount to her team’s success.
Performance Analysis in Major Tournaments
Major tournaments provide the ultimate stage for determining who is the best women’s footballer. Recent World Cups and Olympic Games have showcased exceptional performances:
Tournament | Outstanding Performer | Key Statistics | Impact |
---|---|---|---|
2023 World Cup | Aitana Bonmatí | 3 goals, 2 assists | Led Spain to victory |
2020 Olympics | Vivianne Miedema | 10 goals | Olympic record |
2019 World Cup | Megan Rapinoe | 6 goals, 3 assists | Golden Ball winner |
2016 Olympics | Melanie Behringer | 5 goals | Gold medal |
Impact Beyond the Pitch
The best women’s footballer must demonstrate influence beyond match statistics. This section examines how top players have transformed the sport through their broader impact.
Growing the Game
Leading players have significantly contributed to women’s football’s development:
- Megan Rapinoe’s advocacy for equal pay led to landmark agreements with US Soccer
- Marta’s technical brilliance inspired a generation of Brazilian players
- Alex Morgan’s commercial success opened new revenue streams for women’s football
Social Impact
The influence of elite players extends into social change:
“Football is not just about winning trophies; it’s about inspiring change and opening doors for future generations.” – Ada Hegerberg, first women’s Ballon d’Or winner
Players like Hegerberg have used their platform to advocate for better conditions and equal opportunities in football, making them strong contenders when considering who is the best women’s footballer.
The Next Generation: Rising Stars
The landscape of women’s football continues to evolve with emerging talents pushing the boundaries of excellence. These players are already showing potential to enter the conversation about who is the best women’s footballer.
Linda Caicedo (Colombia)
- Exceptional technical ability demonstrated at 2023 World Cup
- Already starring for Real Madrid at age 18
- Named in IFFHS World Team of the Year
Salma Paralluelo (Spain)
- Olympic sprinter turned footballer
- Key player in Spain’s World Cup victory
- Combines exceptional pace with technical skill
Mary Fowler (Australia)
- Prodigious talent emerging alongside Sam Kerr
- Outstanding performances for Manchester City
- Represents the future of Australian football
Expert Opinions and Analysis
Leading figures in women’s football have provided valuable insights into determining who is the best women’s footballer:
Managers’ Perspectives
Emma Hayes, Chelsea Women’s manager:
“The modern game demands complete players. Someone like Bonmatí exemplifies this – technical excellence combined with tactical intelligence and physical preparation.”
Sarina Wiegman, England manager:
“We’re seeing a new breed of footballer who combines athletic ability with technical mastery. The standards keep rising.”
Technical Analysis
FIFA Technical Study Group findings highlight key attributes of elite players:
- Decision-making speed
- Tactical flexibility
- Technical execution under pressure
- Physical conditioning
- Mental resilience
Measuring Success: Trophies and Individual Awards
Achievement at both team and individual levels provides crucial context when determining who is the best women’s footballer.
Major Individual Awards
Award | Most Wins | Current Holder | Significance |
---|---|---|---|
Ballon d’Or Féminin | Alexia Putellas (2) | Aitana Bonmatí | Most prestigious individual award |
FIFA The Best | Marta (6) | Aitana Bonmatí | Global recognition |
UEFA Player of the Year | Alexia Putellas (2) | Aitana Bonmatí | European excellence |
Team Success
The ability to elevate team performance remains crucial:
- Champions League victories
- International tournament wins
- Domestic league titles
- Impact on team tactics and style
Cultural Impact and Legacy
The best women’s footballer must leave a lasting legacy on the sport. This section examines how top players have influenced football culture and society.
Media Representation
Leading players have transformed media coverage:
- Increased visibility in mainstream sports media
- Social media influence and engagement
- Commercial partnerships and sponsorships
Youth Development
Impact on developing players:
- Creation of academies and development programs
- Mentorship of young players
- Technical innovations in training methods
Comparative Analysis: Different Eras
Comparing players across different eras presents unique challenges when determining who is the best women’s footballer.
Evolution of the Game
Era | Key Characteristics | Notable Players | Playing Conditions |
---|---|---|---|
1970s-1980s | Amateur status | Rose Reilly | Limited resources |
1990s | Semi-professional | Michelle Akers | Growing recognition |
2000s | Professional leagues | Marta | Improved facilities |
2010s | Global expansion | Megan Rapinoe | Full professionalism |
2020s | Elite standard | Aitana Bonmatí | Advanced technology |
Technical Development
The evolution of playing styles and technical requirements:
- Increased tactical sophistication
- Higher physical demands
- Advanced training methods
- Improved equipment and facilities
Frequently Asked Questions
Who holds the record for most international goals?
Christine Sinclair holds the record for most international goals in football (men’s or women’s) with 190 goals for Canada.
How is the best women’s footballer officially recognized?
Through awards such as the Ballon d’Or Féminin, FIFA The Best, and UEFA Player of the Year, along with performance in major tournaments.
Can players from different eras be fairly compared?
While challenging, comparison criteria include relative dominance in their era, technical ability, and impact on the game’s development.
What makes a footballer the ‘best’?
A combination of technical skill, tactical intelligence, physical ability, achievement record, and broader impact on the sport.
How has the definition of ‘best’ evolved in women’s football?
The criteria have evolved from purely technical skills to include tactical understanding, physical preparation, and off-field influence.
Conclusion: Defining the Best Women’s Footballer
After comprehensive analysis of historical and contemporary players, statistical evidence, expert opinions, and impact both on and off the pitch, determining who is the best women’s footballer remains complex. However, certain conclusions emerge:
- Historical Context: The evolution of the game means comparing players across eras requires careful consideration of playing conditions and opportunities.
- Current Standard: Aitana Bonmatí currently sets the benchmark for excellence in women’s football, combining technical mastery with tactical intelligence and winning the sport’s highest honors.
- Legacy Impact: Players like Marta and Michelle Akers have left indelible marks on the sport that transcend pure statistics.
The question of who is the best women’s footballer will continue to evolve as the game develops and new talents emerge. What remains constant is the increasing quality and professionalism of women’s football, producing ever more skilled and complete players who push the boundaries of what’s possible in the sport.